I accept (but disagree) with President Obama’s view that marriage should be between a man and a woman, as a matter of personal religious belief or doctrine. But I do not accept that view from him in his capacity of head of state.
As to the legal issues, if one reads the opinion striking down Proposition 8, it clearly sets out the correct legal premise that the state gives the marriage license and that it need not be consecrated in a religious ceremony. Celebrants of the various religious faiths need not perform same-sex marriages, but it is irrelevant to the actions of the state. The USDA certifies pork and pork products, but many religions prohibit the eating of pork. http://40andoverblog.com/?p=2124
What is the real legal issue? Equal protection under the laws.
As to the social issues, I don’t want anyone’s tolerance. I refuse to rely on someone else’s good graces and “open” mind in order to live my life.